Expectant Parent Call or Text: 800.340.9665
Adoptive Parent Call or Text: 800.340.9665
Serving Expectant Parents Statewide With an Office Located in:

Understanding Contested Domestic Newborn Adoptions: What You Need to Know

When it comes to adoption, it is important to understand all the aspects of the process. One of the most complex and difficult situations can arise when a domestic adoption is contested. But what exactly is a contested adoption? A contested adoption is a legal dispute between the adoptive parents and the birth parents, or any other party involved, over the rights and responsibilities of the adoption process. In this blog post, we will discuss what a contested adoption is, the potential risks, and steps that can be taken to prevent a contested adoption.

Defining Contested Adoptions of Newborns

Adoption is a wonderful and life-changing process that provides infants with a loving home and a brighter future. However, not all adoptions are simple and straightforward. In some cases, adoptions can become contested, which can be a very challenging experience for all parties involved. A contested adoption is a situation where one or more parties contest the legal process of adoption, making it more difficult for the adoption to be finalized. In general, the parties involved can include birth parents, adoptive parents, legal guardians, and the court system. 

The contested adoption process can be lengthy, complicated, and emotionally draining. It involves a variety of legal procedures that require a great deal of knowledge and expertise in family law. The main reason that adoptions become contested is due to a disagreement between the birth parents and adoptive parents regarding the adoption process. This can include a disagreement about the child’s best interests, the suitability of the adoptive parents, or the legality of the adoption.

Common Reasons for Contesting an Adoption

While every contested adoption case is unique, there are certain common reasons why a person might choose to contest a domestic adoption. The majority of the reasons below highlight the necessity of working with a licensed adoption agency to ensure that the adoption process meets all the necessary legal criteria.

Here are some of the most common reasons for contested adoptions:

1. Lack of Consent: One of the primary reasons for contesting an adoption is when one of the birth parents did not give their consent for the adoption. It’s essential for the adoptive parents to have the consent of both birth parents before proceeding with the adoption.

2. Fraud or Misrepresentation: Another reason why someone might choose to contest an adoption is if they were given false information about the adoption. For example, the birth mother may have lied about the birth father’s identity, or the adoptive parents may have misled the birth mother about their financial situation.

3. Coercion or Duress: If the birth parent was coerced or threatened into signing the adoption papers, it can be considered a case of duress. In such cases, the adoption is considered invalid and can be contested.

4. Inadequate Legal Representation: Sometimes, a birth parent may contest an adoption because they didn’t receive adequate legal representation during the adoption process. It is essential for both the birth parent and the adoptive parent to have legal representation during the adoption process to ensure that all legal procedures are followed.

5. Changes in Circumstances: Sometimes, a birth parent may contest an adoption if their circumstances have changed since they signed the adoption papers. For example, if they had originally signed the papers because of financial difficulties, but now have a stable job, they may want to contest the adoption.

These are some of the most common reasons why someone might choose to contest an adoption. It’s important to remember that every adoption case is unique, and there may be other reasons why someone may contest an adoption. If you are considering adoption, it’s crucial to seek the guidance of a licensed adoption agency like Building Arizona Families, who utilizes the legal services of an experienced adoption attorney to ensure that the adoption process is handled legally and ethically.

Legal Procedures Involved in Contested Adoptions

When a dispute arises over an adoption, the legal system becomes involved in resolving the matter. The process of contesting an adoption involves a variety of legal procedures, including petitions to terminate parental rights, court hearings, and evaluations by social workers or mental health professionals. The courts must weigh the interests of the birth parents, the adoptive parents, and the child in determining the outcome of the case. In cases where the biological parents contest an adoption, it can be a lengthy and emotionally charged process. Understanding what a contested adoption is, and the legal procedures involved, are crucial for all parties involved in these complex situations.

The Role of Birth Parents in Contested Adoptions

In contested adoptions, birth parents can have a crucial role to play. These are situations where one or both birth parents contest an adoption are usually due to a disagreement with the adoptive parents or concerns about their child’s safety and well-being. Birth parents may hire legal counsel to fight for custody of their child and prevent the adoption from going through. In some cases, birth parents may argue that the adoption was not legal or was conducted without their consent. The birth parents’ rights and interests are always considered during an adoption being contested, and their involvement in the process is necessary to ensure a fair and just outcome.

The Role of Adoptive Parents in Contested Adoptions

In contested adoptions, adoptive parents also have a significant role to play. They may have invested a great deal of time, money, and emotional energy into the adoption process, and they likely have a deep attachment to the child they have been raising. If a birth parent challenges the adoption, the adoptive parents may be faced with a range of difficult decisions and emotions. It is essential that adoptive parents work closely with their attorney and follow legal procedures to protect their interests and the child’s best interests. They may need to testify in court, provide evidence to support their claim to custody, and participate in mediation or negotiation sessions. Above all, adoptive parents must remain committed to the child’s well-being, regardless of the outcome of the adoption contestation process.

Contested adoptions are complex and even emotional challenges. By being informed and utilizing a licensed adoption agency, you can avoid loopholes that can create this challenging situation and ensure that the child’s welfare is prioritized.  

About Building Arizona Families

Building Arizona Families is a licensed adoption agency that has been serving adoptive families, birth mothers, foster children, and newborn babies since 2004.  We serve birth mothers residing in Arizona, families around the U.S. adopting newborns, and Arizona families adopting foster children from around the country.  Building Arizona Families has an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau, and is also Hague accredited – a very stringent international adoption accreditation process. 

If you are interested in starting your adoption journey, please reach out to us by phone or text at 800-340-9665 or by email info@buildingarizonafamilies.com. Our adoption agency also hosts monthly adoption seminars to help families learn more about the adoption process, we invite you to visit our Facebook page to stay up to date with the current seminar schedule. 

Pin It on Pinterest

Us 24/7

Toll-Free 24/7

Call 24/7

Pregnancy Hotline 24/7


8433 North Black Canyon Highway
Building 6, Suite 152
Phoenix, Arizona 85021